Independent Local Directory
Orlando Custom Cookie Bakers
Compare independent cookie businesses serving Orlando and Central Florida. The current-service notes below were checked against official websites and the newest dated social posts available on October 4, 2026.
Current Ordering and Service Notes
Delivery, pickup and shipping are different services. Use these notes to narrow the list, then confirm your date and address with the bakery before paying.
| Baker | Starting price | Minimum | Lead time | Pickup or delivery | Shipping | Order | Checked |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Southern Home Bakery | Published cookies from $5 each; custom quote may differ | 12 cookies per design | At least 4 business days for pickup; more for delivery or shipping | College Park or Winter Garden pickup; delivery listed by ZIP | U.S. cookie shipping | Location-specific custom request | October 5, 2026 |
| By Steph McNeff | $66 per dozen | 2 dozen | Not published | Local pickup | Nationwide shipping | Email quote request | October 5, 2026 |
| Street Cookies by Emily | $65 per dozen for listed custom sets | 1 dozen | 2 to 3 weeks recommended | Free Orlando pickup; local delivery for $15 | Nationwide shipping | Online order or custom inquiry | October 5, 2026 |
| The Frosted Bite | Printed from $60 per dozen; hand-decorated listed at $78 or $80 per dozen | 2 dozen | At least 2 weeks | East Orlando pickup; limited delivery by request | No shipping | Online quote request | October 5, 2026 |
| Deliada Bakery | Quote required | 12 cookies | Not published | Pickup and Orlando-area delivery | Nationwide shipping for eligible orders | Online event order form | October 5, 2026 |
| Daisy Cakes | $60 per dozen | 1 dozen | At least 2 weeks recommended | Windermere pickup; Orlando-area delivery for a fee | Not published | Website quote request | October 5, 2026 |
| Custom by Sugar Bloom | Not published | Not published | Not published | Not published | Not published | Website inquiry | October 5, 2026 |
Southern Home Bakery
College Park • Winter Garden • Greater Orlando
Two Orlando-area locations for decorated cookies, custom requests and Southern desserts.
View baker profile →By Steph McNeff
Orlando • Nationwide shipping
Handmade custom cookies with local pickup and nationwide shipping details on the official site.
View baker profile →Street Cookies by Emily
Orlando • Greater Orlando • Nationwide shipping
Orlando custom cookies with local pickup and delivery plus nationwide shipping.
View baker profile →The Frosted Bite
East Orlando • Greater Orlando
Active East Orlando home bakery for hand-decorated, logo, photo and printed cookies.
View baker profile →Deliada Bakery
Orlando • Central Florida • Selected nationwide shipping
Custom event treats with Orlando-area delivery and nationwide shipping on selected products.
View baker profile →Daisy Cakes
Windermere • Greater Orlando
Active Windermere home bakery offering custom cookies and cakes for celebrations.
View baker profile →Custom by Sugar Bloom
Lake County • Greater Orlando
Artfully designed custom cookies for Lake County and Orlando-area celebrations.
View baker profile →Own an Orlando Cookie Business?
Add or claim a basic listing free. You can also ask about featured placement and sponsored local pages.